Real-You
VIP
Home
Sue
  • Who am I?
  • Explore with Sue
  • Consultancy
  • Connect
Humanity's Petri Dish
  • The Nocebo Economy
  • Privatizing Being Human
  • Quiet Persuasion
  • Influence Tactics
  • You’ve Been in Trance
  • Hacked Heart of the Home
  • Who Minds Your Mind?
  • Trademarked Amnesia
  • Identity Goalposts
  • Anatomy of Ideology
  • Belief Wears the Brain
  • What's Been Left Out
  • When We Are Infectious
  • The Great Pre-Tender
  • 2 NLPs of Human Psych
  • Oldest Intelligence Scent
Cabinet of Curiosities
  • Power and Consequence
  • Order Interrupted
  • Our Bodies and Screens
  • Addicted to Complexity?
  • When Worry Is Wisdom
  • Wanna Come Out and Play?
  • Present Within Presence
  • Emotions are Indicators
  • Two Worlds, One Breath
  • Tired of Feeling Real?
  • The Mastery of Joy
  • How Groups Shape Thought
  • Sit with Me at the Table
  • The Rhythm Under Methods
  • Imagination Hijacked
  • Tall Poppy Syndrome
Science & Exploration
  • Diving into Neuroscience
  • Regulation & Integration
  • Let's Go Quantum
Testimonials
Real-You
VIP
Home
Sue
  • Who am I?
  • Explore with Sue
  • Consultancy
  • Connect
Humanity's Petri Dish
  • The Nocebo Economy
  • Privatizing Being Human
  • Quiet Persuasion
  • Influence Tactics
  • You’ve Been in Trance
  • Hacked Heart of the Home
  • Who Minds Your Mind?
  • Trademarked Amnesia
  • Identity Goalposts
  • Anatomy of Ideology
  • Belief Wears the Brain
  • What's Been Left Out
  • When We Are Infectious
  • The Great Pre-Tender
  • 2 NLPs of Human Psych
  • Oldest Intelligence Scent
Cabinet of Curiosities
  • Power and Consequence
  • Order Interrupted
  • Our Bodies and Screens
  • Addicted to Complexity?
  • When Worry Is Wisdom
  • Wanna Come Out and Play?
  • Present Within Presence
  • Emotions are Indicators
  • Two Worlds, One Breath
  • Tired of Feeling Real?
  • The Mastery of Joy
  • How Groups Shape Thought
  • Sit with Me at the Table
  • The Rhythm Under Methods
  • Imagination Hijacked
  • Tall Poppy Syndrome
Science & Exploration
  • Diving into Neuroscience
  • Regulation & Integration
  • Let's Go Quantum
Testimonials
More
  • Home
  • Sue
    • Who am I?
    • Explore with Sue
    • Consultancy
    • Connect
  • Humanity's Petri Dish
    • The Nocebo Economy
    • Privatizing Being Human
    • Quiet Persuasion
    • Influence Tactics
    • You’ve Been in Trance
    • Hacked Heart of the Home
    • Who Minds Your Mind?
    • Trademarked Amnesia
    • Identity Goalposts
    • Anatomy of Ideology
    • Belief Wears the Brain
    • What's Been Left Out
    • When We Are Infectious
    • The Great Pre-Tender
    • 2 NLPs of Human Psych
    • Oldest Intelligence Scent
  • Cabinet of Curiosities
    • Power and Consequence
    • Order Interrupted
    • Our Bodies and Screens
    • Addicted to Complexity?
    • When Worry Is Wisdom
    • Wanna Come Out and Play?
    • Present Within Presence
    • Emotions are Indicators
    • Two Worlds, One Breath
    • Tired of Feeling Real?
    • The Mastery of Joy
    • How Groups Shape Thought
    • Sit with Me at the Table
    • The Rhythm Under Methods
    • Imagination Hijacked
    • Tall Poppy Syndrome
  • Science & Exploration
    • Diving into Neuroscience
    • Regulation & Integration
    • Let's Go Quantum
  • Testimonials
  • Home
  • Sue
    • Who am I?
    • Explore with Sue
    • Consultancy
    • Connect
  • Humanity's Petri Dish
    • The Nocebo Economy
    • Privatizing Being Human
    • Quiet Persuasion
    • Influence Tactics
    • You’ve Been in Trance
    • Hacked Heart of the Home
    • Who Minds Your Mind?
    • Trademarked Amnesia
    • Identity Goalposts
    • Anatomy of Ideology
    • Belief Wears the Brain
    • What's Been Left Out
    • When We Are Infectious
    • The Great Pre-Tender
    • 2 NLPs of Human Psych
    • Oldest Intelligence Scent
  • Cabinet of Curiosities
    • Power and Consequence
    • Order Interrupted
    • Our Bodies and Screens
    • Addicted to Complexity?
    • When Worry Is Wisdom
    • Wanna Come Out and Play?
    • Present Within Presence
    • Emotions are Indicators
    • Two Worlds, One Breath
    • Tired of Feeling Real?
    • The Mastery of Joy
    • How Groups Shape Thought
    • Sit with Me at the Table
    • The Rhythm Under Methods
    • Imagination Hijacked
    • Tall Poppy Syndrome
  • Science & Exploration
    • Diving into Neuroscience
    • Regulation & Integration
    • Let's Go Quantum
  • Testimonials

Same Elephant from Different Angles

A reflection on persuasion, history, and lived intelligence

For years, I’ve been interested in the stories people carry without necessarily remembering where they came from.

Ideas about who we are, what is safe, what matters and what kind of person we should be can become so familiar that they simply feel like us.

Sometimes we notice the effect in conversation. A belief sounds rehearsed rather than explored. An opinion is defended with an intensity that seems larger than the subject itself. Something in us tightens before we have quite worked out why.

That doesn’t prove manipulation.

But it can be enough to make me curious.

Recently I came across Rebecca Lemov’s The Instability of Truth, a historical exploration of brainwashing, mind control and persuasion. She traces attempts to influence belief and identity through very different settings, from prisoners of war and coercive groups to mass media and modern digital environments.

It didn’t feel like discovering a completely new subject.

It felt like meeting the same elephant from another angle.


When Influence Becomes an Environment

Historical work on coercive persuasion often involves extreme conditions such as isolation, repetition, uncertainty, emotional pressure and dependency.

Those conditions matter because they can restrict the information available to a person and increase the power of whoever controls the environment.

Modern advertising, politics, therapy, social media and self-improvement are not equivalent to a prisoner-of-war camp, and I don’t think it helps to pretend they are.

But there is still an interesting question underneath the comparison.

What happens when influence stops arriving as an obvious instruction and becomes part of the environment we live inside?

Advertising surrounds us. Platforms learn from our behaviour. Political messages appeal to identity and belonging. Therapy and self-help introduce language that can eventually become the way we describe ourselves.

None of this automatically removes our agency.

But it does mean influence can become ordinary enough that we stop recognizing it as influence.

That interests me.


When Influence Becomes Identity

One of the more unsettling ideas in the history of persuasion is that control does not always feel like control to the person experiencing it.

Lemov uses the phrase “brainwashing erases itself.”

The idea is not that every strongly held belief has secretly been implanted. People arrive at beliefs for all sorts of reasons, including evidence, experience, culture, relationships and deliberate thought.

But influence becomes much harder to examine when the belief has become part of identity.

“This is just how I think.”

“This is who I am.”

“I’ve always believed this.”

Maybe.

Or perhaps the belief has a history we no longer remember.

The interesting question is whether we can look at that history without feeling that our entire self is being placed on trial.

If an idea can be examined, questioned and even discarded without destroying who we are, it remains an idea.

When questioning the idea begins to feel like a threat to the self, something else may be happening.


Life Inside Constant Persuasion

We now live in environments where extraordinary amounts of information compete for our attention.

Every scroll, notification, headline and recommendation offers something else to react to.

That can be useful. We have access to more knowledge, people and perspectives than most humans in history could have imagined.

It can also be exhausting.

Research on digital environments describes information overload, social overload, communication demands and constant connectivity as possible sources of technostress. More recent research has also linked rapid online interaction with attentional fragmentation, cognitive load and emotional exhaustion.

That doesn’t mean everyone using social media is living in a state of permanent nervous system collapse.

It means our attention has limits.

When we are repeatedly asked to react before we have time to think, certainty can become attractive.

A clear villain.

A clear answer.

A group that already knows what is happening.

Sometimes the relief of certainty is more seductive than the uncertainty of investigation.


The Body Carries Part of the Story

This is where I still think lived experience deserves a seat at the table.

Stress, uncertainty and emotional pressure can show up physically. Breathing changes. Muscles tighten. Sleep shifts. Attention narrows.

But I want to be careful here.

The body is not a lie detector.

A tight chest does not prove the person in front of us is manipulating us. A sense of relief does not prove a belief is true.

Physical responses tell us that something is happening in our experience.

Then curiosity gets a turn.

What am I responding to?

Is this familiar?

What else is happening around me?

Does the explanation I’ve been given actually fit?

The body gives us information. It does not always give us the interpretation.

That distinction has become increasingly important to me.


Lived Intelligence Is Still Evidence

I don’t mean “evidence” in the scientific sense of proving a general claim.

I mean evidence about our own experience.

If a person repeatedly feels confused, pressured or smaller within a particular relationship or system, that experience deserves attention.

It doesn’t automatically tell us why it is happening.

But neither should it be dismissed simply because it hasn’t yet been translated into somebody else’s approved language.

People often blame themselves first.

Maybe I’m weak.

Maybe I’m overthinking.

Maybe I’m too sensitive.

Sometimes that may be true in part. We humans are perfectly capable of misreading situations.

But confusion can also be a reasonable response to contradictory information or an environment where the rules keep changing.

Fatigue can be feedback without becoming a diagnosis.

Discomfort can be worth examining without becoming proof.

That is what I mean by lived intelligence.


Why Different Angles Matter

Some people trust historical records. Others are drawn to science, philosophy, personal experience or patterns they notice in everyday life.

I like putting those angles beside each other.

History can show us precedent.

Science can investigate mechanisms and test explanations.

Lived experience can tell us what something felt like from inside it.

None automatically proves the others.

But sometimes one angle gives us language for something another angle has already made us notice.

That was my experience reading Lemov.

The history didn’t prove every suspicion I’ve ever had about influence.

It gave me another way to investigate the question.

Same elephant.

Different angle.


The Quiet Return of Authority

The answer is not to distrust everything.

That becomes another trap remarkably quickly.

I’m more interested in returning some authority to observation and curiosity.

Does this information make sense when I slow down enough to examine it?

What evidence supports it?

Who benefits if I accept it?

What happens if I disagree?

Am I free to ask questions without having my character, intelligence or belonging placed at risk?

And what is my own response telling me?

Not as absolute truth.

As information.

I think that difference protects us from simply replacing one authority with another.


Presence and Persuasion

An earlier version of this piece said that influence depends on disconnection and that presence undoes it.

That was too absolute.

People can be fully present and still be influenced. We influence each other constantly.

What presence may give us is a little more room to notice.

A pause before agreement.

Enough time to recognize an emotional hook.

A chance to ask whether a conclusion actually belongs to us or simply arrived packaged with the experience.

Slowing down doesn’t make us immune.

It makes examination more possible.

And that is probably enough.


Same Elephant. Still Breathing.

The history of persuasion is not evidence that somebody is secretly controlling every aspect of modern life.

It is evidence that humans have spent a very long time studying how belief, attention, emotion and identity can be influenced.

We also know that influence is not always obvious to the person experiencing it.

That seems worth remembering.

Not so we become suspicious of everyone.

Not so every uncomfortable feeling becomes proof of manipulation.

But so we leave enough room to ask where our stories came from and whether they still deserve the authority we give them.

History gives me one angle.

Science gives me another.

My own experience gives me another again.

None shows the whole animal.

Same elephant.

Different angle.

And still, quietly, breathing.



Sources and Further Reading

Rebecca Lemov, The Instability of Truth: Brainwashing, Mind Control, and Hyper-Persuasion (2025)
https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/782347/the-instability-of-truth-by-rebecca-lemov/

Naga and Ebardo, Social Network Sites as an Archetype of Techno-Social Stress: A Systematic Review (2025)
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39811382/

Panigrahi et al., Psychology at Digital Speed: A Systematic Review of How Rapid Online Interaction Alters Cognitive and Affective Processes (2026)
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42508353/

Ungerleider and Wellisch, Coercive Persuasion (Brainwashing), Religious Cults, and Deprogramming (1979)
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/420323/

If you enjoy exploring ideas like this, you can receive future essays by email.

Receive New Essays

Copyright © 2026 Real-You VIP - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by