For most of human history, there was no modern mental health industry telling us how to manage, optimize or monetize the “mind.”
People certainly thought deeply about inner life, suffering, behaviour and meaning. But the idea of the mind as something to diagnose, improve, track and sell solutions for is relatively new.
If you’ve ever felt that your thoughts, fears, hopes or “mental health” are being shaped, steered or sold back to you, that feeling has a history. And I think it matters.
Before the Mind Became a Market
Across cultures, humans have always explored inner life, although they have understood it in very different ways.
In Christian traditions, thought has often been woven together with ethics, conscience and responsibility. Buddhist traditions developed practices involving attention, awareness and the nature of suffering. Across Australia’s diverse Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures, relationships with Country, kinship, ancestry, law, language and identity can carry meanings that don’t fit neatly into the Western idea of an isolated individual mind.
These traditions are not interchangeable, and there is no single ancient worldview we can bundle together as “the old way.”
What interests me is something simpler. Inner experience has not always been treated as a private machine operating inside a sealed skull. It has also been understood through relationship, responsibility, meaning, community and place.
Not endlessly dissected. Not endlessly sold.
Freud: Turning Inner Life into a System
Sigmund Freud changed the cultural story.
He didn’t invent the unconscious or the exploration of inner life, but psychoanalysis gave Western society an enormously influential new language for talking about unconscious drives, repression, inner conflict and hidden desires.
Psychoanalysis proposed that much of what influences us sits outside conscious awareness and may require interpretation to understand. That was powerful. It offered new ways of talking about suffering, helped normalize the exploration of emotion, memory and childhood experience, and made inner life something people could discuss more openly.
But it also did something else.
It turned subjectivity into a system that could be analysed, categorized and interpreted.
Much of Freud’s specific theory remains controversial. Some ideas have not held up well under scientific testing, while others influenced later psychological approaches that moved far beyond Freud himself.
His cultural influence, though, is hard to miss. The private world inside us increasingly became something professionals could examine from the outside.
That can be useful. It also raises an interesting question: at what point does someone else’s interpretation of our experience begin carrying more authority than our own?
Bernays: When Psychology Became Persuasion
Edward Bernays, Freud’s nephew, took psychological ideas and put them to work in public relations.
He understood that people don’t make decisions only by comparing facts. Meaning, identity and association matter too.
His famous 1929 “Torches of Freedom” campaign linked public cigarette smoking by women with ideas of independence and liberation. For Beech-Nut, he used physician endorsements of a “hearty breakfast” to help promote bacon and eggs.
He didn’t simply sell products. He sold meanings.
A cigarette could become freedom. Breakfast could become health and tradition. The product had not changed. The story around it had.
Bernays wasn’t solely responsible for joining psychology and marketing, but he became one of the clearest early examples of how psychological ideas could be deliberately used to shape public attitudes.
The inner world had become useful commercial territory.
Mental Health in the Age of Packaging
Modern psychology and mental healthcare have helped enormous numbers of people understand themselves, receive treatment and reduce suffering. That matters.
But surrounding that legitimate work is now a huge marketplace of apps, programs, protocols, productivity systems, wellness products and self-help industries.
Some are genuinely useful. Some are not. And some carry a quieter message underneath the promise of improvement: perhaps something about you is wrong, someone else knows how to fix it, and you need one more explanation, treatment, program or framework before you can finally feel okay.
Meanwhile, social pressure, economic strain, loneliness, difficult relationships, digital overload and exhausting living conditions can easily become framed primarily as individual problems.
The person adapts while the conditions around them remain untouched.
I don’t think every struggle can be blamed on “the system,” any more than every struggle should be blamed on the individual. But if we only ever ask what is wrong with the person, we can miss a fairly important part of the picture.
The Algorithmic Mind
Today, influence doesn’t always need a public relations firm. Some of it lives in code.
Recommendation systems use our behaviour to predict what we might want to see next. What we click, watch, share and linger on can all become information used to shape what appears in front of us.
Those systems aren’t literally reading our minds, and they don’t know everything about us. But our behaviour generates data, and that data can help determine what gets shown back to us.
Attention has commercial value. Uncertainty can become engagement, and engagement can become profit.
That means the information environment around us is not simply something we choose. It is also being continually shaped in response to what we do.
The “mind” is no longer only something we experience privately. Parts of our attention and behaviour have become commercially valuable information.
That is worth noticing.
Consciousness as Relationship
There is another way of looking at human experience that keeps pulling at my attention.
Not because I want to romanticize Indigenous cultures or borrow traditions that aren’t mine, but because relational ways of understanding life challenge something Western culture often takes for granted.
Across many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures, Country can encompass much more than physical land. It can include family, identity, language, law, spiritual belief, responsibility and relationship.
Those cultures are diverse. There is no single Indigenous philosophy of consciousness, and I’m not pretending there is.
What catches me is the relationship.
The human being is not necessarily treated as a completely separate unit observing the world from the outside. We exist in relationship with place, people, history, environment and meaning.
That feels important, especially in a culture increasingly interested in reducing human experience to data points, diagnoses and performance metrics.
Who Really Minds Your Mind?
Freud helped popularize a language for inner conflict. Bernays demonstrated how psychological understanding could be used in persuasion. Technology has given influence extraordinary reach and speed.
These are different histories. They are not one continuous plot.
But put them beside each other and something interesting appears.
Our inner lives have become increasingly measurable, interpretable and commercially useful.
Slowly, the story can shift from “I am part of something alive” to “I am a psychological unit to be managed.” From “awareness happens in relationship” to “attention is a resource.” From “imagination helps us make meaning” to “imagination is content.”
So maybe the question isn’t only who is shaping your thinking.
Maybe it is also what kind of inner world you are living inside.
One built around fear, optimization and constant correction, or one with room for relationship, curiosity and lived experience?
Reclaiming Consciousness
Reclaiming your awareness doesn’t mean rejecting psychology, therapy, science or technology. It doesn’t mean assuming every institution is manipulating you or that your intuition is automatically correct.
It means not outsourcing your entire sense of self.
It means noticing when your attention is being pulled, prodded or harvested, listening to your body’s feedback without turning every sensation into unquestionable truth, and remaining curious about the relationship between your experience and the explanations being offered to you.
Your rhythms, your relationships and your lived experience still matter.
So does your ability to notice when something doesn’t sit right and then get curious about why.
Before the mind became a product, inner life existed in relationship with breath, place, other people and meaning.
That relationship is still available.
No subscription required.
Sources and Further Reading
American Psychological Association, APA Dictionary of Psychology: Psychoanalysis
https://dictionary.apa.org/psychoanalysis
American Psychological Association, Psychoanalysis and Psychoanalytic Therapies
https://www.apa.org/pubs/books/psychoanalysis-psychoanalytic-therapies-second-edition
Museum of Public Relations, Bernays and the Origins of Modern PR
https://www.prmuseum.org/educator-exchange-classroom-guide-bernays-and-the-origins-of-moder-pr
American Psychological Association, Psychoanalysis Shapes Consumer Culture
https://www.apa.org/monitor/2009/12/consumer
AIATSIS, The Little Red Yellow Black Book: An Introduction to Indigenous Australia
https://aiatsis.gov.au/publication/34972
AIATSIS, Welcome to Country: What is Country?
https://aiatsis.gov.au/explore/welcome-country
Meta, How AI Influences What You See on Facebook and Instagram
https://about.fb.com/news/2023/06/how-ai-ranks-content-on-facebook-and-instagram/
Created October 6, 2025 revised September 2026